This Portfolio discusses one of the most challenging problems in the federal securities laws: complying with rules against lying through omission.
To access this Portfolio, take a free trial to the Bloomberg BNA Financial Accounting Resource Center
This Portfolio is part of the Accounting Policy and Practice Series, an essential resource including more than 70 accounting Portfolios and the latest news and developments.FREE TRIAL
I. Nature of Duty
B. Scope and Contents of Portfolio
II. Legal Foundations of Disclosure Requirements
A. Line Item Requirements
B. General Disclosure Requirements
2. Antifraud Rules
3. Nonfraud Rules
C. Application of the Duty to Avoid Material Omissions
D. Implications for Principles-Based Accounting
E. Regulation FD
III. Development of the Duty to Avoid Material Omissions
A. Rule 10b-5
1. Adoption of the Rule
2. Ward La France Truck Corporation
a. Facts Leading to Stock Sales
b. Initiation of SEC Investigation
c. SEC's Analysis
d. Emergent Principles
B. United States v. Simon
C. 1984 Interpretive Release
IV. The Heart of the Duty to Avoid Material Omissions: Materiality
A. The Basic Test of Materiality: TSC Industries, Inc. v. Northway.
1. Objective Standard
2. Comparison to Accounting Standard
B. Avoid Numerical Tests: Basic Inc. v. Levinson
C. SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin 99
1. Background and Purposes
2. Key Points
D. Ganino v. Citizens Utility Company
E. SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin 108
F. Limitations of Boilerplate Disclosure
1. Westinghouse Securities Litigation
2. Rubenstein v. Collins
3. Huddleston v. Herman & MacLean, et al.
4. Summary as to Boilerplate
V. The Duty to Correct Prior Disclosures
VI. The Duty to Update Prior Disclosures
C. SEC Rule 14a-9
VII. Application of the Duty to Avoid Material Omissions in the SEC Enforcement Process
A. Materiality Generally in the SEC Enforcement Process
1. In the Matter of Richard P. Scalzo, CPA
2. Microsoft Corporation
B. Cases Applying the Duty to Avoid Material Omissions
1. The Need to Disclose Matters Involving the Survival or Viability of the Company
a. Stansbury Holdings Corporation
b. Dauphin County General Authority
c. Former Kmart Executives
d. Biopure Corporation
e. Former Officers and Directors of Spiegel, Inc.
2. The Truth About Operations and Performance
a. Trump Hotels & Casino Resorts, Inc.
b. Massachusetts Turnpike Authority
c. Charter Communications, Inc.
d. McLeodUSA Incorporated
e. Elan Corporation
f. Craig Scott
g. Former Qwest Communications Executives
h. Time Warner
i. Global Crossing Ltd.
j. The Coca Cola Company
k. Mount Sinai Medical Center of Florida, Inc.
l. Bio One Corporation
m. MBIA, Inc.
n. Tenet Healthcare Corporation
3. Failure to Reveal Improper Accounting or Accounting Error
a. Gerber Scientific, Inc.
b. Warnaco Group, Inc.
c. Fleming Companies, Inc.
d. Dennis O'Connor
e. Gregory A. Brady, William M. Beecher and Reagan L. Lancaster
f. John R. Behrmann
g. Former Bristol-Myers Squibb Officers
h. Martin E. Kenney, Jr.
i. Netopia, Inc.
j. Former Comverse Technology Officers
k. Walid H. Maghribi
l. Steven J. Landmann and Gary C. Gerhardt
m. International Business Machines Corporation
4. Management Integrity
a. Washington County Utility District
b. Former Enron Officers
5. Management Compensation and Benefits
a. W.R. Grace & Co.
b. Tyson Foods, Inc. and Donald Tyson
6. Regulation FD
a. Motorola Investigative Report
b. Flowserve Corporation
7. Causing Violations
b. Example: Ture Roland Fahlin
8. Summary of Enforcement Actions
VIII. Planning Points: Practical Guidelines for Evaluating Materiality of Undisclosed Information
A. General Considerations
1. Basic Elements
2. Materiality Will Be the Crucial Question
3. Avoid Reliance on Quantitative Measures
4. Contingent or Speculative Disclosures
5. Be Candid in Using the Guidelines
6. Application of Guidelines to Misstatements
7. How to Use the Guidelines
B. Planning Point: What If Others Learn of the Information?
1. What would a major shareholder, or creditor, of the company, who is not affiliated with management or any insider, think about the information?
2. What if the disclosure counsel at the company's outside law firm found out?
3. What if the company's auditors learned of the information?
4. What reaction would the SEC staff likely have if they found out?
5. Would a governmental agency be likely to take action if it became aware of the information?
6. Would you be concerned about your employment situation at the company if the information were not disclosed?
7. Would the employment status of a member of executive management of the company come into question if disclosure were made?
8. Would a significant proportion of the company's customers, suppliers or vendors be concerned if they were to learn of the information?
9. Are you tempted to destroy, discard, alter or conceal records relating to the information so that the company's auditors and the SEC cannot find out about it?
10. Do you feel the need to keep dual sets of records in order to keep track of the company's activities and be able to reconcile them with the company's publicly filed financial reports?
11. Have others within the company tried to conceal the information?
12. Consider information relating to debt covenants
13. Consider discretionary dealings with creditors.
14. If a reporter learned of the information, would he or she be interested in writing a story about it?
15. Is the information something in which a stock analyst would be interested?
16. Is the information something that a rating agency would like to know?
C. Pecuniary Considerations
1. Does the information in question make you feel poorer (in the case of negative information) or wealthier (in the case of positive information)?
2. Do you think the company stock's price would change if and when the information is disclosed? If so, by how much?
3. Have others in the company argued against disclosure because they stand to make money or avoid losing money, from nondisclosure? Are you tempted to withhold or delay disclosure for the same reason?
4. Does the information make you want to buy or sell the company's stock or options before disclosure is made?
5. Do you have reason to believe that others in the company who know of the undisclosed information have traded in the company's stock because of the information, or have tipped others who may have traded?
6. If your family or in-laws hold stock in the company, would they be annoyed with you for not tipping them off in advance about the information?
7. If you were making a bid for the company, would the information lead you to consider adjusting the price you would pay for the company or withdrawing your bid?
8. Would disclosure make the company more vulnerable or less vulnerable to an unwanted takeover bid?
9. Would disclosure of the information pressure management and the board to consider strategic change, such as placing the company or a significant part of the company up for sale?
10. Would a labor union representing company employees regard the information as important to ongoing or future contract negotiations?
D. Other Considerations
1. Are there anomalies in the company's sales or shipment of goods?
a. The Coca Cola Company
b. Walid H. Maghribi
2. Is the company having product development problems?
3. Guidance from SAB 99 Concerning Quantitatively Small Items
4. Guidance from SAB 99 and SAB 108 Concerning Multiple Misstatements and the Aggregation of Immaterial Misstatements
5. Does the Omission Significantly Affect the Presentation of Management Compensation or Perquisites?
E. Summary of Planning Points
TABLE OF WORKSHEETS
Worksheet 1 TSC Industries Inc. v. Northway Inc., 426 U.S. 438 (1976)
Worksheet 2 Basic Inc. v. Levinson, 485 U.S. 224 (1988)
Worksheet 3 Ganino et al. v. Citizens Utility Co. et al., 228 F.3d 154 (2d Cir. 2000)
Worksheet 4 In the Matter of The Purchase and Retirement of Ward La France Truck Corporation Class "A" and Class "B" Stocks, 13 S.E.C. 373 (1943)
Worksheet 5 United States v. Simon et al., 425 F.2d 796 (2d Cir. 1969), cert. denied, 397 U.S. 1006 (1970)
Worksheet 6 Public Statements by Corporate Representatives, Securities Exchange Act Release No. 33-6504 (Jan. 13, 1984)
Worksheet 7 In the Matter of Trump Hotels & Casino Resorts Inc., Securities Exchange Act Release No. 34-45287 (Jan. 16, 2002)
Worksheet 8 In the Matter of Massachusetts Turnpike Authority and James J. Kerasiotes, Securities Act Release No. 33-8260 (July 31, 2003)
Worksheet 9 In the Matter of Dauphin County General Authority, Securities Act Release No. 33-8415 (April 26, 2004)
Worksheet 10 In the Matter of Ture Roland Fahlin, Securities Exchange Act Release No. 34-50519 (Oct. 13, 2004)
Worksheet 11 In the Matter of The Coca Cola Company, Securities Act Release No. 33-8569 (April 18, 2005)
Worksheet 12 SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin: No. 99 - Materiality, Exchange Act Release No. SAB 99, 17 C.F.R. Part 211
Worksheet 13 U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin: No. 108, Financial Statements (Sept. 13, 2006), 17 C.F.R. Part 211
Worksheet 14 SEC v. Tenet Heathcare Corporation, David L. Dennis, Thomas B. Mackey, Christi R. Sulzbach, and Raymond L. Mathiasen, Civil Action No. CV 07-2144 (C.D. Cal. April 2, 2007), Complaint
U.S. Department of Justice Materials:
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission Materials:
SEC Administrative Proceedings:
SEC Staff Bulletins and Staff Guidance:
SEC Press Releases:
SEC Litigation Releases:
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants
Financial Accounting Standards Board
New York Stock Exchange
The Nasdaq Stock Market, Inc.
American Stock Exchange
Bureau of National Affairs, Inc.
The Wall Street Journal
All Bloomberg BNA treatises are available on standing order, which ensures you will always receive the most current edition of the book or supplement of the title you have ordered from Bloomberg BNA’s book division. As soon as a new supplement or edition is published (usually annually) for a title you’ve previously purchased and requested to be placed on standing order, we’ll ship it to you to review for 30 days without any obligation. During this period, you can either (a) honor the invoice and receive a 5% discount (in addition to any other discounts you may qualify for) off the then-current price of the update, plus shipping and handling or (b) return the book(s), in which case, your invoice will be cancelled upon receipt of the book(s). Call us for a prepaid UPS label for your return. It’s as simple and easy as that. Most importantly, standing orders mean you will never have to worry about the timeliness of the information you’re relying on. And, you may discontinue standing orders at any time by contacting us at 1.800.960.1220 or by sending an email to email@example.com.
Put me on standing order at a 5% discount off list price of all future updates, in addition to any other discounts I may quality for. (Returnable within 30 days.)
Notify me when updates are available (No standing order will be created).
This Bloomberg BNA report is available on standing order, which ensures you will all receive the latest edition. This report is updated annually and we will send you the latest edition once it has been published. By signing up for standing order you will never have to worry about the timeliness of the information you need. And, you may discontinue standing orders at any time by contacting us at 1.800.372.1033, option 5, or by sending us an email to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Put me on standing order
Notify me when new releases are available (no standing order will be created)