By Daniel Gill
A transfer that was designed to place assets outside of the reach of creditors by sending them to Venezuela was not an avoidable fraudulent transfer, because the transferor was not the debtor, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled.
In a split decision, the Jan. 3 opinion by Judge Marjorie O. Rendell interpreted Delaware law and found that without properly alleging that the transferor is a debtor, the action must fail.
Crystallex International Corp. was a Canadian company owning rights to mine gold in Venezuela. In 2011, Venezuela nationalized its gold mines and expropriated Crystallex’s rights to the mine.
Crystallex won an award of $1.2 billion in an arbitration proceeding against Venezuela before the World Bank.
But Venezuela made clear through public statements, including by former president Hugo Chavez, that it had no intention of ever paying this or similar awards.
Venezuela and its alleged alter ego, Petroleos de Venezuela, caused a series of transfers to occur, to remove assets from the United States and repatriate the funds to Venezuela.
Citgo Petroleum and its holding companies were Delaware corporations. The U.S. holding company was owned by Petroleos, Venezuela’s alleged alter ego.
Citgo liquidated its interest by issuing debt. The $2.8 billion it raised was passed up through the holding companies as “dividends,” the court explained, until ultimately the money was repatriated in Venezuela, which enjoys sovereign immunity from civil actions.
Crystallex alleged that this was a fraudulent transfer, made by a debtor with the intent to hinder and delay creditors.
The Third Circuit found that the transferors here were not in fact debtors, such that a fraudulent transfer claim could not stand. In fact, the court pointed out, the debtors here were the transferees, the recipients of the fraudulent conveyance, not the party making the transfer. That the transferors were ultimately owned by the debtors was of no consequence, the court held.
The court also found that there was no cause of action for aiding and abetting a fraudulent transfer, or for conspiracy.
Judge Julio M. Fuentes dissented, arguing that Delaware’s fraudulent transfer laws couldn’t reasonably be interpreted to allow such an intentionally fraudulent transfer to be free from recovery by creditors. He argued that these were indirect transfers of Petroleos and therefore were recoverable.
Judge Thomas I. Vanaskie joined in the opinion.
Nathan P. Eimer, Chicago, argued on behalf of the Citgo holding company. Crystallex was represented by Robert L. Weigel, New York.
The case is Crystallex Int’l Corp. v. PetróLeos De Venezuela, S.A. , 2018 BL 1031, 3d Cir., No. 17-1439, 1/3/18 .
To contact the reporter on this story: Daniel Gill in Washington at firstname.lastname@example.org
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Jay Horowitz at email@example.com
Copyright © 2018 The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
All Bloomberg BNA treatises are available on standing order, which ensures you will always receive the most current edition of the book or supplement of the title you have ordered from Bloomberg BNA’s book division. As soon as a new supplement or edition is published (usually annually) for a title you’ve previously purchased and requested to be placed on standing order, we’ll ship it to you to review for 30 days without any obligation. During this period, you can either (a) honor the invoice and receive a 5% discount (in addition to any other discounts you may qualify for) off the then-current price of the update, plus shipping and handling or (b) return the book(s), in which case, your invoice will be cancelled upon receipt of the book(s). Call us for a prepaid UPS label for your return. It’s as simple and easy as that. Most importantly, standing orders mean you will never have to worry about the timeliness of the information you’re relying on. And, you may discontinue standing orders at any time by contacting us at 1.800.960.1220 or by sending an email to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Put me on standing order at a 5% discount off list price of all future updates, in addition to any other discounts I may quality for. (Returnable within 30 days.)
Notify me when updates are available (No standing order will be created).
This Bloomberg BNA report is available on standing order, which ensures you will all receive the latest edition. This report is updated annually and we will send you the latest edition once it has been published. By signing up for standing order you will never have to worry about the timeliness of the information you need. And, you may discontinue standing orders at any time by contacting us at 1.800.372.1033, option 5, or by sending us an email to email@example.com.
Put me on standing order
Notify me when new releases are available (no standing order will be created)