Verizon-CWA Pact Preserves Generous Lump Sum Pensions

Employee Benefits News examines legal developments that impact the employee benefits and executive compensation employers provide, including federal and state legislation, rules from federal...

By David B. Brandolph

June 7 — Verizon Communications Inc. employees returning to work under a tentative contract can take comfort that innovative bargaining has likely preserved their right to generous pension lump-sum payouts.

As part of the recent collective bargaining pact between Verizon and the Communications Workers of America, the company agreed to retain a lump-sum payment calculation that uses generous discount interest rate assumptions in exchange for the union's agreement to lock in 2016 mortality tables.

Verizon made the deal knowing that long-awaited Internal Revenue Service mortality table updates are coming and will carry a hefty price tag, Robert Patrician, with the CWA's research department in Washington, told Bloomberg BNA June 3 ( 52 PBD, 3/17/16 ).

Mortality tables project plan participants' life expectancies and are used in calculating lump-sum pension distributions designed to match lifetime annuity pensions.

When Verizon proposed scrapping the lump-sum option altogether during bargaining, the union responded by agreeing to an innovative freeze of the plan's mortality table assumptions for the life of the 38-month contract, Patrician said.

This was a concession the union was willing to make because its members value the lump-sum option and because the deal permitted the union to retain a plan provision giving participants the most favorable discount rate from among a choice of three rates, he said. This provision assures that participants will get to use the lowest interest rate and thus receive the highest possible payments, he said.

The union particularly wanted to retain under the agreement the choice of using the 30-year Treasury bond yield, he said. For a number of years, this rate has been significantly lower than the other two plan choices—the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation rates and the Internal Revenue Service segment rates under the Pension Protection Act of 2006.

‘Small Windfall' for Retirees

Overall, the lump-sum payouts that Verizon will offer plan participants under the new contract represent a “small windfall” for retirees, John Lowell, pension consultant for October Three in Atlanta, told Bloomberg BNA June 1.

The contract's freezing of the mortality tables would keep lump-sum payments “slightly lower” than what would be anticipated from the longer life expectancies that future IRS mortality tables are expected to incorporate, Lowell said. However, that contract feature is more than made up for by the agreement's use of the lower 30-year Treasury bond yield, he said.

For example, using current mortality tables and current discount rates, Lowell calculated that a 65-year-old Verizon plan participant retiring on June 1 would receive a lump-sum benefit about 13 percent higher under the new contractual provisions than he or she would receive if the agreement used the segment-rate approach that is the minimum under the PPA.

This is a “no lose” situation for the union and plan participants, Lowell said. For the plan to remain qualified under the tax code, the new contractual provision governing lump-sum payouts must provide a lump sum to participants that is at least equal to the payout participants would receive under the PPA, he explained.

A representative from Verizon told Bloomberg BNA June 6 that the company won't comment on any of the contract's provisions, given that the agreement remains tentative and requires union member ratification. Voting is expected to be completed by about June 20.

To contact the reporter on this story: David B. Brandolph in Washington at

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Jo-el J. Meyer at

Request Pension & Benefits Daily