Woody Allen Quote From Faulkner Novel In 2011's 'Midnight in Paris' Not Infringing

Bloomberg Law®, an integrated legal research and business intelligence solution, combines trusted news and analysis with cutting-edge technology to provide legal professionals tools to be...

By Anandashankar Mazumdar

A quotation from a William Faulkner novel as used in a 2011 Woody Allen movie constituted fair use and thus did not give rise a claim of copyright infringement, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Mississippi ruled July 18 (Faulkner Literary Rights, LLC v. Sony Pictures Classics Inc., N.D. Miss., No. 3:12-cv-00100-MPM-JMV, 7/18/13).

Granting a motion to dismiss, the court noted particularly the very different natures of the original novel and the movie and concluded that the use was highly transformative.

Faulkner Quotation Widely Used

From his base in northern Mississippi, William Cuthbert Faulkner (1892-1962) authored some of the most highly regarded works of American literature, including short stories, screenplays, essays, letters, plays, and--most significantly--19 novels, many of them set in the fictional Yoknapatawpha County, Miss., including The Sound and the Fury (1929) and As I Lay Dying (1930).

In 1950, Faulkner published the novel Requiem for a Nun, which centers on the protagonist's efforts to save her nanny from being executed for the death of her child. The novel features one of Faulkner's most famous lines, spoken by the protagonist's attorney:

The past is never dead. It's not even past.

This line has been widely quoted, including in March 2008 by then-U.S. Sen. Barack H. Obama Jr., in a famous speech on race relations, given in reaction to a media firestorm surrounding his relationship with the Rev. Jeremiah A. Wright Jr.

Woody Allen (born Allan Stewart Konigsberg in 1935) is one of America's best-known screenwriters and directors of dramatic and comedic films. In his 2011 comedic film Midnight in Paris, Gil Pender, a character played by actor Owen Wilson, travels back in time to the Paris of the 1920s and the 1890s, where he meets many of the great literary and artistic figures of those times, including William Faulkner. At one point in the movie, Pender says the line:

The past is not dead! Actually, it's not even past. You know who said that? Faulkner. And he was right. And I met him, too. I ran into him at a dinner party.

Faulkner Literary Rights L.L.C., which administers Faulkner's intellectual property rights, sued Sony Pictures Classics Inc., the studio that released Midnight in Paris, alleging that this line from the movie constituted infringement of Faulkner's copyright.

Sony Pictures moved for dismissal under Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6) for failure to state a claim for which relief is available under the law.

Court Alludes to Less Literary Works

Granting dismissal, Judge Michael P. Mills began by quipping about a creative work with less literary prestige than those of Faulkner or Woody Allen, specifically, a made-for-basic-cable disaster movie featuring Tara Reid and Ian Ziering by noted “knockbuster” producer the Asylum, and premiered by the SyFy Channel in 2013:

The court has viewed Woody allen's movie, Midnight in Paris, read the book, Requiem for a Nun, and is thankful that the parties did not ask the court to compare The Sound and the Fury with Sharknado.

Turning to the substance of the claims, the court determined that the use of the line in the Woody Allen movie constituted fair use. In reaching this decision, the court applied the four-factor balancing test as set forth in the Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. §107.

Addressing the first factor, the purpose and character of the use in the movie, the court found that the Faulkner novel and the Woody Allen movie were very different from each other. The court said:

Here, a weighty and somber admonition in a serious piece of literature set in the Deep South has been lifted to present day Paris, where a disgruntled fiancé, Gil, uses the phrase to bolster his cited precedent … in a comedic domestic argument with [his fiancée]. Moreover, the assertion that the past is not dead also bears literal meaning in Gil’s life, in which he transports to the 1920′s during the year 2011. It should go without saying that this use is highly distinguishable from an attorney imploring someone to accept responsibility for her past, a past which, to some extent, inculpates her for the death of her child.

Characters in both works use the quote for antithetical purposes of persuasion. On one hand is a serious attempt to save someone from the death penalty, and on the other is a fiancé trying to get a leg up in a fleeting domestic dispute.

This extreme difference between the two works made the Woody Allen use transformative, the court said, especially considering the “miniscule amount borrowed” from Faulkner.

Turning to the factor addressing the nature of Faulkner’s work, the court determined, while declining to determine whether the Woody Allen use constituted a parody, that this factor favored neither side.

Regarding the substantiality of the portion of Faulkner’s work used by Woody Allen, the court said that not only was the quotation very small compared to the side of the work, but it also constituted “only a small portion of the expression of this idea throughout the novel,” the idea in question being that the past cannot be forgotten.

Finally, the court found no compelling evidence that the use of the quotation in the movie would have any negative effect on the market for Faulkner’s novel.

Considering this factor, the court said that even if it could be shown that Woody Allen had used the line in a bad faith attempt to injure the value of Faulkner’s work, such a showing would not be relevant.

The court dismissed as meritless claims under the Lanham Act and Mississippi state commercial misappropriation law.

Faulkner Literary Rights was represented by J. Cal Mayo Jr. of Mayo Mallette, Oxford, Miss. Sony Pictures was represented by Christian Dominic Carbone of Loeb & Loeb, New York.

Text is available at http://www.bloomberglaw.com/public/document/Faulkner_Literary_Rights_LLC_v_Sony_Pictures_Classics_Inc_Docket_.

Request Bloomberg Law®